You are not alone! I also don't agree with the idea of my husband digging under my dress so I wanted him to keep the garter in his pocket and throw it just like that and I will throw my bouquet, but he still doesn't like the idea so I don't know what else to do... but I really want him to throw the garter without exposing my legs...
Bride.2012 could you pin it to the inside of your dress?? Near the hem??
So that when he goes to get it he all you need to do it pull your dress up a little to show your ankle and he can just unpin?
You don't have to have it all the way up your leg...
There was another suggestion earlier on where a lady said that she would shuffle it down her leg, you could do the same and then kick it off and make HIM catch it before he throws it! Could be a fun idea!
Hope gives you some ideas!!