I HATED my wedding photos from 5 years ago from the moment I got them back. They were just terribly done, she hadn't taken any effort to get unusual or arty types of pics, they were just your standard posed photos and I was/am so disappointed.
However, trying to get my DH to pose for photos once was hard enough, there is no way I could get him to do it again!
But if your DH is ready and willing, I say go for it! But there would be just that little niggly feeling in me when looking at them that it wasn't my true wedding day.