Hey apmr14 - Congrats and Welcome!
I loved Kershaw House - but I too have heard some iffy things - but I haven't been to a function there so, I dont really know!
Shame if the food at customs house isn't great as I agree with Steph it really is a pretty place in a great location!
Goldston House is beautiful!
If you're planning on Sept 25 though, I'd be checking availability - Sept's pretty busy around here - we looked at venues in July and Kershaw House, Goldston House, Rosslyn Bay Inn, and Rydges Chapel were already booked our weekend, I also know that Customs House is now booked our weekend too - and that's only the week before yours! Dont want to put a downer on it hun, but if you really really want one of the places you listed, I'd be calling them ASAP just to see if they're available. From what I understand Oct isn't quite as bad, but still popular!
Anyways - good luck with the planning hun, oh, and you've picked your dress!! Pics?
Merry Christmas to all the Rocky girls